The Bibs vs Coveralls Question

FR bibs are the better choice if you want to adjust your layers through the day, while insulated FR coveralls give you the most complete coverage against wind and cold. Both keep your legs and core warmer than work pants alone, and if you work around arc flash or flash fire hazards, whichever you pick should be FR.

As fall turns to winter, this is one of the most common questions crews ask. Here's how to choose the best winter FR clothing for your lower half, based on how you really spend your day.

What's the difference between FR bibs and coveralls?

FR bibs, also called bib overalls, are an overall pant with a chest panel and shoulder straps. You wear them with an FR jacket or hoodie on top. FR coveralls are one piece that covers your torso, arms, and legs all at once.

Both come in insulated versions for winter. The difference is really about how much you want to adjust as the day goes on.

When are FR bibs the better pick?

Bibs shine when your work is active. Climbing, hauling, and working in a bucket all build heat, and bibs let you control it from the top. Take your jacket off when you're working hard, then throw it back on during a break, and your legs and lower back stay warm the whole time.

Bibs also give your shoulders and arms more freedom, since nothing ties your upper body to your legs. And because they work with any FR jacket, you can switch between a heavy parka and a lighter shell as the weather changes. Our FR bibs and coveralls collection has insulated and lined options for the colder months.

When do insulated FR coveralls make more sense?

Coveralls are hard to beat for long hours in bitter cold and open wind. With no gap at the waist, there's nowhere for cold air to sneak in when you bend or reach. They're a great fit for work where you're outside for long stretches, like standby, inspections, or remote sites in the far north.

Because coveralls hold heat so well, it helps to start your shift a little on the cool side and plan for warm up breaks. Leg zippers make them easier to pull on over your boots.

Do you still need an FR jacket with bibs?

Yes. Bibs cover your legs and core, so your arms and upper body need their own FR outer layer. A bomber pairs especially well with bibs, since the bibs already cover your lower back. If you're shopping for one, our guide to the best FR jackets for winter walks you through parkas, bombers, and liner kits.

What should you wear under FR bibs or coveralls?

Start with a moisture-wicking FR base layer so sweat moves away from your skin. Under bibs, most people add FR work pants and an FR shirt. Under coveralls, a base layer and a light FR mid layer are often enough, since the coverall does so much of the work.

Whatever you wear, keep every piece FR from skin to shell. If you're layering to reach a certain arc rating, use combinations that have been tested together. Our layering calculator shows you which ones, and our post on winter FR layering covers the full system.

Which insulated FR coverall do we recommend?

When the cold really sets in, our pick is the MWG STORMSHIELD™ Men's FR Insulated Coverall. It's fully insulated and built from STORMSHIELD™, our inherently flame-resistant ripstop fabric that's windproof and waterproof. It carries a CAT 4 rating with a 49 cal arc rating, and silver reflective striping on the torso, arms, and legs helps you stay visible. It also comes in tall sizes for a better fit through the body.

MWG STORMSHIELD Men's FR Insulated Coverall, a winter FR coverall in bright orange with silver reflective striping

MWG STORMSHIELD™ Men's FR Insulated Coverall

If bibs suit your work better, the STORMSHIELD™ Men's FR Insulated Overall brings the same fabric in a bib style, and the RIPGUARD™ Men's FR Lined Overall adds a knit lining for cool days. Women can shop fits made for them in our women's FR bibs and coveralls.

Not sure which way to go for your crew? Send us a message and we'll help you sort out the right mix of bibs, coveralls, and jackets for the season ahead.

 

Back to blog